Brief for the Prime Minister
By Thuraisingham Shun
A. Preamble
The Malaysian Cooperative movement is today, 89 years. It consists of 8500 cooperatives with a membership of over 9 million snowballing to 17 million with family members included.
B. Memorandum sent
- 8 memorandum in detail have been forwarded to the Prime Minister
- 1 memorandums has been handed to the Deputy Prime Minister.
- Memorandum had been handed to the former minister with 2 copies referred to YB Ismail Sabri
- 1 memorandum had been forwarded to the Chief Secretary and the Secretary General
- Lately on 28th July, a memorandum had been handed to the Deputy Minister.
We have yet to receive any feedback on the same as yet.
C. 8 point originating summons against ANGKASA
The salient features are:
1) Taking more than RM1 million in allowances for attending board meetings from 2007-2009.The president was accused of taking RM155,118 in 2008.
2) Failing in their fiduciary responsibilities in a land purchase in Kelana Jaya
and causing a loss of RM6.5 million in the deal with the Malaysian Association of Productivity.
3) Approving and spending RM500,000 for a delegates’ conference, including allowances in 2009,in violation of by-laws.
- Spending RM1.27 million to buy seven Toyota Camry for personal use before Hari Raya last year while only RM400,000 was authorized for the purpose.
- Approving and spending RM500,000 over and above the sanctioned budget of RM1.5 million in 2009 without permission.
- Abusing their powers in suspending three members of the state liaison committee for three years.
- Paying unauthorized allowances to officials of the Malaysians Cooperative Societies Commission and other government officials who attended several board meetings. These payments were viewed as corruption.
- Making false media statements Angkasa had made a profit of RM2 billion for the financial year ending June 30 last year
D. The co-operative commission had acted on 3 of the above matter which favours the plaintif.
E. Misstated accounts of the Cooperative Commision for the year ending 2008 & 2009 has been passaged through parliament ENCLS 3
Salient features:
- Billions not accounted
- Fund accounts mismanaged
- Cooperative Commission deemed illegal
F. ANGKASA is an illegal entity.
G. SPARK of problems
– Suspension of 9 individual members
– Report sent to Deputy Minister
H. 8 Bumiputra co-operative suspended
– Double standards practiced by Minister
– Thousands of Bumiputra co-operative members in a delima
I. Illegal launch of Co-operative Bank in parliament lobby
J. Illegal school Co-operatives
K. Schemers from the Cooperative movement
-Dato’Dr.Ali Baharom implicated in a multimillion Ringgit money laundering scheme and organizer of the illegal- ANGKASA Cooperative Bank
-Has now intrued into the palace and religious centres
Conclusion
ANGKASA and the officials of the Co-operative Commission have mislead the Minister in their activities in controversion of the Cooperative Act
______________________________________________________________________
Proposed Solutions
A direction from PM to Angkasa to release the 9 individual suspension.
The co-operative movement which is a people oriented organization should be transferned under the purview of the Prime Minister
A Overall Programmed Evaluation of Management Audit
Appoint an “OPERATIONS DIRECTOR” to conduct the day to day administration of the Co-operative Commission
Appoint an “ADMINISTRATOR” to conduct:
A forensic audit
To conduct the day to day administration of ANGKASA
Food for thought (Confidential)
The role of co-operatives in the election process
The Thai political movement is controlled by the Telecoms Co-operative spearheaded by Thaksin
The Singapore government election is monopolized by the activities of the NTUC-cooperative
The co-operatives in Indonesia play a pivotal role in the election process
The India Co-operative movement plays a pivotal role in the election of the government
………………………………………………
Thuraisingham Shan
Co-operative a Management Consultant
Advisor/Consultant
Cooperative Union of Malaysia
Midlands Co-operative Union
International Cooperative Housing Foundation
International Director –UKHWAH
FOUNDATION for International Co-operative
………………………………………………………………
Dato’ Seri Hj Mustapa Kamal bin Maulut
Chairman
Portfolio Koperasi
The National Malay Chambers Commerce Malaysia