Mahathir and Razaleigh: Two peas in a pod?
Razaleigh’s 2009 reform road map is more clear and comprehensive than anything from Mahathir.
Koon Yew Yin, Free Malaysia Today
Over the past 10 years I have written a great deal about national politics and the country’s leadership. In particular I have focused on our Prime Ministers in response to the policies they initiated and the way they have managed the key issues and challenges of our multi-racial society and developing economy.
Besides writing about Dr Mahathir Mohamad, Abdullah Badawi and Najib Razak, I have also written extensively on two political figures who could have become Prime Ministers but never quite made it: Anwar Ibrahim and Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah, also known as Ku Li.
My view of Mahathir has not been charitable: in fact, it will be considered unkind. Most Malaysians, including a majority of Malays today, will agree with me that he is a failed leader who has let down the country badly.
Malaysians of my generation, with longer memories than the current generation, who know of the stability, harmony and prosperity that we enjoyed, as well as experienced the high standards of governance inherited from the British, see the son of Mohamad Iskander Kutty, Mahathir, as the principal cause of our badly dysfunctional economy and society.
The worst legacy of the man regarded as “Bapa Malaysia” by such groups as Perkasa lies not in the form of his cock-ups such as Proton, MAS, Perjawa Steel, and not even in the cronies he favoured, resulting in a disproportionate proportion of the country’s wealth being held by a few.
Perwaja Steel, MAS and even Proton can be erased from the books overnight. Cronies can be compelled to renegotiate their contracts so that national interests are protected.
His legacy is actually the dominant party, Umno, which runs the country and which Mahathir has shaped into a right-wing, Ketuanan Melayu party which has placed Malay special interests above all else.
Umno is the nation’s bully who has destroyed many of our important institutions such as the judiciary, while fostering cronyism, impoverishing our economy, and undermining many of our basic rights and freedoms.
Mahathir is the man who nurtured this bully to what it has become today: an oppressive grouping of Umno-putras functioning like a baby’s alimentary canal with a healthy appetite at one end and no responsibility at the other.
Imagine my surprise therefore to read of Mahathir’s resignation from the party he helped transform into a party of patronage and pirates.
When the news reached me. I had emailed friends the following note: I see Dr M has resigned from Umno. I now have some respect for him and I lost my respect for Tengku Razaleigh.
Since then he has become the main figure in the unveiling of the Citizens’ Declaration which is aimed at getting rid of the current Prime Minister.
There is some talk of broad political reform in the document. But in his latest speeches, it looks like Mahathir does not think there is much wrong with Umno and he is apparently waiting to return to Umno the moment Najib leaves the scene.
If that happens, I will have to withdraw my initial reaction of having some respect for Mahathir. I hope that Mahathir gives up completely on Umno and helps the opposition come to power. That way, he will atone for the mistakes he has made and leave a positive legacy.
