Some Questions For The Salafi / Wahabi Braders And Maybe For The Candidates For Mufti FT
OutSyed the Box
Non Muslims will find this to be plodding. You can skip if you wish.
Christians who know the Bible may find this interesting.
Muslims do read this – even if it is plodding.
I thought I would raise some questions and points on this lazy Wednesday for the renungan of the brader-brader salafi / wahabi and maybe for the interest of any of the possible candidates for the position of the FT Mufti.
1. Ke mana perginya kesemua khutbah Jumaat nabi / Where have all the prophet’s Friday sermons gone?
They say that :
the Prophet was born in 570 AD.
his mission began in 610 AD. He was 40 years old.
the Israʾ dan Miʿraj happened on 621 AD (the FIVE daily prayers story).
The prophet was 51 years old.
The Hijrah to Madinah took place on 623 AD. The prophet was 53 years old.
Upon his arrival in Madinah the prophet built the first mosque ie the Masjid Quba. Hence the first Friday sermon was also held at that Masjid Quba in 623 AD.
The prophet died in 632 AD at age 62.
In the nine years (623 AD – 632 AD) after he built the Masjid Quba and till his death in 632 AD there were 468 weeks (my mistake earlier).
Where are the complete records of 468 (at least) of these Friday sermons?
Where is the full set?
The Sahih Bukhari does not have a complete record of all the prophet’s Friday sermons. (Selain khutbah jumaat pertama dan terakhir).
How come the Sahih Bukhari does not have the full set of all the prophet’s Friday sermons? The salafi / wahabis are ready to condemn people and even sentence people to death based on the Sahih Bukhari. Surely Friday sermons are extremely important. So where are the complete records of ALL the prophet’s Friday sermons?
2. When Bukhari died he did not leave behind a complete book or fully compiled edition of the Sahih Bukhari.
There is no such thing as the original version of Bukhari’s book written and compiled by his own hands. The most widely accepted version of the Sahih Bukhari was compiled by Ibnu Hajar Askalani who died in 1449 AD ie 450 years after Bukhari.
So there was no original version of Sahih Bukhari written by the hands of Bukhari himself. Can anyone explain this?
3. The Quran does not say that the Torah / Taurat was revealed to Moses / Nabi Musa. The Quran says that Moses was given a book ‘Kitab’ or ‘Suhuf’.
Sila rujuk Surah 17:2 “wa aataina musa al kitaaba” – “dan Kami telah memberikan kepada Musa al Kitab”.
Sura 87:19 ‘suhufi ibraheem wa musa’ – the ‘books’ (suhoof) of Abraham and Moses.
There is no direct mention that Moses was given the Torah / Taurat.
There is no mention of Moses and the Torah together in any verse in the Quran.
